Pass Muster Media My Social Feed

The Tech

One piece, many forms

When one piece shows up as an article, a voiceover and a video, a site should show it once, with a way to listen or watch.

4 min read

Writers today publish the same work in several forms. There is the article, then a voiceover of it, maybe a video, and sometimes a rerun weeks later. On the platform each one is its own post with its own date. To a reader scrolling an archive, it looks like the same title three times.

When we built our first creator site, we counted before we decided anything. In one writer's archive of 2,515 posts, 751 were another version of a piece already posted: a voiceover weeks later, or the audio and the video of the same show. That is nearly a third of the list.

Why it matters

The folding rule

The builder (build.mjs) groups posts by title, inside one publication. Titles are normalized first, then compared. Two rules keep it safe:

  1. Only titles of five or more words are grouped. A short title like "Peaceful Friday" could easily be a series name, used on different days for different pieces. Those are left alone.
  2. Same publication only. Two different publications can share a title without being the same piece.

Within a group, the versions are ranked: article first, then short read, discussion, video and audio. The top one leads the entry. If another version is a video or audio of a different kind, we link it as Listen or Watch. The counts of every version are added together, so likes, comments and restacks all belong to the piece. If a live recording is in the group, the entry keeps its live details and its guests, which matters for the guest list.

Copies from other places

The same idea covers other sites. A YouTube video or a Medium post with the same title as a Substack piece is marked as a copy. It is hidden when you browse all sources, so each piece appears once, and shown when you pick that source. Choose YouTube, and you see every YouTube video.

A creator site says so on its page: "N posts are a voiceover, video or audio version of a piece; here each piece shows once, with a Listen or Watch link."

What reruns looked like in the data

The same writer's podcast was a good example. Articles with a voiceover attached go into the podcast on publish day. Then 230 of them went out again about 72 days later (the median gap) as separate audio posts. Another 66 shows had been posted once as video and once as audio. Listeners and email subscribers could get the same piece twice.

That is not a mistake by the writer. Reruns can be a perfectly good choice, and folding hides them from the archive, not from the podcast. But it is worth seeing, which is why the numbers we keep include a row for reruns and other versions: how each version does against the original, matched by title within each publication.

The trade-off

Folding by title is a simple rule, and simple rules miss things. A piece whose voiceover has a changed title will not fold. A very short title that really is a repeat will not either. We accept that, because the other error is worse: merging two different pieces would hide real work. We would rather show one repeat than lose one article.

The monthly chart on a creator site is honest about it too. It counts every version, and says so. The archive shows pieces; the chart shows output.

If you publish in many forms, this is the whole idea: let the reader find the piece once, and let the form be a choice at the end. See what we build for writers on Creator Sites.

← All posts